“Absurd and Ridiculous that Somebody Enjoying a Saxophone with Robotic Cats is Going to be Arrested ” — NYPD and MTA Workforce As much as Take Down Midtown Busker


A fixture of the Herald Sq. subway cease, John Ajilo — additionally often called the “Dancing is Happiness” man — has been a unusual, welcome sight for a lot of commuters over the previous 5 years. The subway saxophonist, normally posted close to the W34th Avenue and sixth Avenue entrance, and generally at Port Authority/Occasions Sq., ceaselessly carried out impromptu live shows for vacationers and locals alike, backed up by a jaunty ensemble of robotic cats on the Midtown stations.

However all of that got here to a  jarring shut on Thursday, as a crowd of six law enforcement officials converged on Ajillo, handcuffing and arresting him for (the NYPD say) “impeding pedestrian movement and using a sound replica system.” 

NPYD officers arrest busker John Ajilo on the thirty fourth Avenue subway station.

“I’m not obstructing the legislation, I’m not committing any crime,” mentioned Ajilo as he was forcibly restrained by officers Thursday night. Whereas permits should not required to carry out underground, in response to Gothamist officers cited “complaints from the MTA concerning an unauthorized performer” and an MTA rule guide stating that performances can not intervene with the movement of consumers via the station and that there are limits on “sound replica units.”

Stated Pat Warren, MTA Chief Security and Safety Officer of the incident in an announcement: “The MTA has guidelines of conduct which might be for the security of all riders and staff and should not non-obligatory. We admire the Mayor’s and police commissioner’s dedication to conserving Latest Yorkers protected by guaranteeing these guidelines are noticed throughout the transit system.” 

“We will’t have it each methods. Let’s not inform law enforcement officials to do a job after which after they do the job, we activate them and state that they have been being heavy-handed,” mentioned Mayor Eric Adams of the video displaying the officers drag Ajilo away. “They weren’t heavy handed. They have been affected person. He was heavy handed and ignoring them after which he grew to become loud and disruptive to attract consideration.”

“My wrist is injured from the tight handcuffs, Am emotionally depressed, and my physique hurts. My saxophone was broken, our dancers have been incomplete and damaged too after they have been launched to me,” posted Ajilo on Instagram as he recounted the ordeal, including that he spent the evening in jail earlier than being dealt 4 tickets, “all for a struggling subway road musician attempting to maintain household and my 4 autism / autistic kids and the group musically,” he added. 

Because the Adams administration guarantees to amp up subway safety following issues over rider security, town’s beloved subway entertainers and road distributors have change into the NYPD’s go-to goal, inciting anger from Latest Yorkers who consider town sources are grossly misdirected. “Arrest precise criminals as an alternative of being ineffective,” commented one Twitter person, whereas one other mentioned of the cops: “That is so infuriating. They’re actually ruining town, financially and culturally. And when you need a protected MTA, why wouldn’t you wish individuals like this placing in a loving and dependable presence, bringing individuals collectively? Cops are an delinquent power. Society is security.” 

“It’s a battle on music,” mentioned Sal Salomon, a Hell’s Kitchen native, longtime busker, and acquaintance of Ajilo’s. “On this current local weather — the place there may be a lot happening with the Supreme Court docket, with crime in Latest York Metropolis, with the elimination of protections towards hid weapons, the psychological well being points which might be plaguing the subways  — the buskers within the subway are the one hyperlink to somewhat little bit of momentary pleasure and civility in our metropolis.”

Busker Sal Salomon “it’s absurd and ridiculous that somebody enjoying a saxophone with robotic cats goes to be arrested.” Photograph: Phil O’Brien

“If we’re so frightened about security, it’s absurd and ridiculous that somebody enjoying a saxophone with robotic cats goes to be arrested and that we’d use so many sources — law enforcement officials, squad vehicles, judges and courtroom staff — to arrest the buskers who are only bringing pleasure to our metropolis. These officers needs to be ashamed of themselves,” added Salomon.

The NYPD’s give attention to arresting distributors and performers is a hot-button situation citywide. Final month, after a road vendor was pinned and handcuffed for promoting fruit on the Broadway Junction subway station, Adams argued: “There’s a motive now we have a Division of Well being Requirements. If persons are simply promoting meals with none type of insurance coverage of the standard of their meals, somebody may get ailing from that, in order that’s why there are guidelines within the subway system.” Metropolis Council Speaker Adrienne Adams countered: “We should present financial alternatives for Latest Yorkers who’re pursuing them, not criminalize or push them into the justice system.” 

Salomon was ticketed $140 for performing Frank Sinatra tunes in Central Park. “I used to be utilizing a Bluetooth speaker,” he mentioned. “When you take heed to your individual music on the garden via a Bluetooth speaker, there’s no situation, however when you’re performing, they’ll hassle you. It’s not concerning the quantity,” he mentioned, including that in Ajilo’s case, “there may be speculated to have been a meter to find out if the speaker was too loud — in any other case, the officers have been “illegally making a judgment name on what’s ‘too loud’. It’s a battle on performers.”

Like Ajilo, Salomon pressured that the majority artists performing within the subway or park are only attempting to get by in an unforgiving inventive financial system. “Residing in NYC may be very costly, and artists have needed to go to the streets with no different selection to attempt to survive and make ends meet. You’re not assaulting anybody, you’re not robbing anybody — artists want freedom.”

In Ajilo’s case, Latest Yorkers have come out in droves to indicate their help, expressing their dismay at his arrest and donating 1000’s to the musician’s GoFundMe web page in hopes that he’ll be again at his submit quickly, bringing pleasure to a metropolis that desperately wants it. 

John Ajilo performing in Occasions Sq. along with his sax and robotic cats in April this yr. Photograph: Phil O’Brien